Insurance Denies a Medical Claim? Here’s What You Can Do
By: Bryan Tropeano

Few things are more frustrating than opening a letter or checking your insurance portal only to find that your medical claim has been denied. You’ve already dealt with the stress of getting care, scheduling appointments, and waiting for results. Now you’re left with the added burden of figuring out how to pay or how to fight back. When insurance denies a medical claim, it can feel overwhelming, but it’s not necessarily the end of the road. Tools like the Avibra app can help you track and manage your claims, giving you a clearer picture of your insurance process and next steps.

I still remember when a close friend of mine had surgery to repair a torn ACL. The procedure was pre-approved, or so he thought. A few weeks later, a notice came in the mail stating the claim was denied due to a “clerical error.” He panicked, staring at a bill that looked more like the cost of a new car than a medical procedure. After some back-and-forth with the hospital billing department and several phone calls with his insurance provider, the issue was resolved. However, those stressful few weeks showed me how often insurance denies a medical claim, sometimes without providing much explanation. It also made me realize how different types of coverage, like Life Insurance or disability insurance, can play an important role in giving people peace of mind when unexpected health costs arise.

Why insurance companies deny claims

Understanding why an insurance company denies a medical claim is the first step in addressing it. Sometimes the denial is legitimate, but at other times, it’s a simple coding mistake or a missing piece of paperwork. Common reasons include:

  • The procedure or treatment isn’t covered under your plan
  • Lack of pre-authorization or referral
  • Errors in billing codes submitted by the provider
  • Missing or incomplete documentation
  • Claims filed after the submission deadline

Knowing the reason is critical because it determines your next course of action. Always read the denial letter carefully, and don’t hesitate to contact your insurance provider to clarify any questions you may have.

Steps to take after a denial

When insurance denies a medical claim, don’t assume you have to accept the decision. You often have options, but you need to act quickly and stay organized to make the most of them.

1. Review the Explanation of Benefits (EOB):

The EOB should break down what was covered, what wasn’t, and why. Compare this with your policy documents.

2. Contact your healthcare provider’s billing office:

Many denials stem from administrative errors. Providers deal with insurance paperwork daily and can often resubmit claims or fix mistakes on your behalf.

3. Call your insurance company:

Ask for specifics on why the claim was denied. Take notes with names, dates, and reference numbers. This documentation can be critical if you file an appeal later.

4. File an appeal:

Every insurer is legally required to provide an appeals process. When insurance denies a medical claim, you have the right to challenge it. Appeals usually involve submitting a letter along with supporting documentation from your doctor.

5. Escalate if needed:

If your internal appeal is denied, you may be entitled to an external review by a third party. Rules for this vary by state and policy, but it’s worth exploring.

The emotional side of denial

It’s easy to talk about policies and processes, but when insurance denies a medical claim, there’s an emotional toll. You’re already dealing with an injury or illness, and now financial uncertainty is added to the mix. This can make people feel powerless, but it’s important to remember that denials are common, and many are overturned on appeal. Persistence matters more than you think.

Tips for improving your chances

To reduce the chances that insurance denies a medical claim in the first place, consider the following tips:

  • Always verify with your provider that a procedure is covered before proceeding.
  • Keep copies of all communications, referrals, and authorizations.
  • Make sure claims are submitted on time.
  • Ask for written confirmation when you receive pre-approval

The healthcare system is complicated, and insurance companies don’t always make it easier. However, staying proactive can save you time and stress in the long run.

When to Seek Outside Help if Your Insurance Denies a Medical Claim

Sometimes, no matter how much effort you put in, you hit a wall. If insurance denies a medical claim and the appeals process doesn’t work, you might consider outside help. Medical billing advocates specialize in reviewing claims and negotiating with insurers. In more complex cases, you may even need to consult an attorney who focuses on healthcare law. While these steps may not be necessary for everyone, they can be helpful in large, high-stakes bills.

Wrapping it all up

Having insurance deny a medical claim can feel like the system is working against you. But it doesn’t always mean you’re stuck with the bill. By taking the time to understand why a claim was denied, appealing when it makes sense, and seeking help when needed, you give yourself a real chance of turning the decision around.

It’s not easy, and it’s rarely quick, but persistence can make all the difference. If you ever find yourself in this situation, remember—you’re not the only one, and you do have options.

FAQ: When Insurance Denies a Medical Claim

Q: Why do insurance companies deny claims?
A: Common reasons include procedures not covered, missing pre-authorization, billing errors, incomplete documentation, or late submissions.

Q: Can I appeal a denied claim?
A: Yes. Every insurer offers an appeals process, usually involving a letter and supporting documents from your doctor.

Q: How can I fix a denied claim?
A: Contact your provider’s billing office, review your Explanation of Benefits, and submit an appeal with all necessary paperwork.

Q: What if my appeal is denied?
A: You may request an external review or consult a medical billing advocate or attorney specializing in healthcare law.

Q: How can I prevent future denials?
A: Confirm coverage before procedures, keep records of communications, and ensure claims are submitted on time.

About the Author: Bryan Tropeano is a senior producer and a regular reporter for NewsWatch. He lives in Washington D.C. and loves all things Tech.